A GIS-Based Framework for Spatial Compatibility Analysis in Sequential Urban Infrastructure Planning
11/11/2026 –, Multifuncional (Remoto)

Context and problem
Urban sprawl, particularly the dispersed, distant, and disconnected form, is one of the main challenges to urban sustainability and planning. Infrastructure and service planning is highly constrained by budgetary limitations, preventing the simultaneous fulfillment of all needs, whether from a reactive or proactive approach. In this context, a location that is optimal for meeting current population needs may no longer be the most suitable option when considering future stages of urban expansion and the incorporation of new complementary infrastructure.
Geospatial decision-support tools can evaluate infrastructure investments beyond a single planning horizon, assessing whether a new investment is spatially compatible with future expansion stages.

Research gap
Various location-allocation models have been developed to address this problem, identifying optimal locations under given conditions and considering one or more optimization objectives. These approaches provide efficient solutions for a specific scenario, but they generally assume a single planning horizon and a static representation of the urban system. In practice, urban infrastructure expansion occurs gradually, so an optimal solution for an initial stage may no longer be suitable when complementary infrastructure is incorporated later. The problem ceases to be solely about locating a new facility and becomes instead about planning a spatially consistent sequence of investments over time.
Consequently, current GIS-based location and allocation approaches offer limited support for long-term infrastructure planning under dynamic urban growth conditions, underscoring the need for a framework capable of assessing whether an optimal decision made today remains spatially compatible with future scenarios of successive investment decisions for expansion of the same infrastructure.

Objective and case study
The present study aims to develop a GIS-based decision-support framework that introduces the proposed Spatial Compatibility Analysis (SCA) as a criterion for sequential urban infrastructure planning. It evaluates the persistence of candidate solutions across successive expansion stages, identifying spatially compatible configurations that remain consistent over time and avoiding initial decisions that may compromise future infrastructure development.
The approach is applied to Ciudad Juárez, Mexico, using the existing fire station network as a case study. The proposed framework integrates geospatial information to evaluate sequential expansion scenarios and identify the spatial compatibility of candidate locations under different infrastructure growth strategies. As this work relies on commonly available geospatial datasets, it can be readily transferred to other cities and adapted to different types of service-oriented infrastructure.

Methodology
This methodology consists of four sequential stages integrating geospatial analysis using Geographic Information Systems (GIS), Spatial Compatibility Analysis (SCA), and multi-objective optimization tools for sequential urban infrastructure planning. The methodology uses spatial information on population distribution, urban boundaries, and existing infrastructure to represent the city's current territorial configuration and to evaluate expansion scenarios.
First stage. Three successive expansion scenarios were selected to represent typical phased infrastructure investments under medium-term planning conditions. They correspond to the addition of one, two, and three new fire stations (N+i), where N represents the number of existing stations and i the number of stations proposed for addition. For each candidate configuration generated for the (N+i) scenario, a Thiessen tessellation is constructed to delimit each station's area of influence and to calculate the objective functions.
Second stage. For each expansion scenario, five independent runs of a multi-objective optimization algorithm are performed, each using an initial random population of 20 candidate configurations. Starting with these populations, the algorithm generates successive generations using an elitist selection scheme, crossover, and mutation, until the evolutionary process converges and the Pareto front stabilizes. This procedure enables the assessment of the repeatability of spatial convergence patterns.
Third stage. A final set of non-dominated solutions (Pareto fronts) is generated, representing spatially efficient configurations that satisfy the objective functions of population coverage and territorial balance.
Fourth stage. The Pareto fronts obtained for each expansion scenario constitute the basis for the SCA. The evaluation of the persistence of Pareto-optimal convergence regions across successive infrastructure expansion scenarios defines the SCA. The comparison is based on the criteria of recurrence and spatial correspondence between the convergence regions defined by the Pareto-optimal solutions obtained across the different expansion scenarios. This procedure allows for identifying persistent solutions as the configurations that remain spatially consistent across different levels of expansion, representing robust alternatives for long-term planning.
Likewise, incompatible solutions are identified, corresponding to locations that are efficient in an initial stage but cease to be part of the convergence regions identified in subsequent scenarios upon incorporation of new complementary infrastructure. The spatial recurrence of Pareto-optimal solutions allows the delimitation of spatially compatible expansion corridors, understood as regions with high compatibility between successive scenarios and with greater potential to guide the gradual planning of urban infrastructure.

Expected contributions
The main contribution of this work is the introduction of the Spatial Compatibility Analysis as a criterion for the sequential planning of urban infrastructure using Geographic Information Systems (GIS). Unlike conventional location-allocation approaches, this methodology not only identifies optimal configurations for a specific scenario but also evaluates the permanence of these solutions as expansion scenarios evolve.
The approach provides a tool to support long-term investment decision-making under budget constraints, favoring strategies that maintain efficiency in successive expansion stages. Furthermore, the methodology can be extended to the planning of hospitals, police stations, fire stations, schools, transportation systems, and other types of service infrastructure.
Unlike conventional location-allocation models, the proposed framework evaluates the compatibility of successive investment decisions rather than independently optimizing each expansion stage. The proposed SCA introduces spatial persistence as a criterion for evaluating the long-term consistency of infrastructure investment decisions across successive expansion scenarios, enabling the identification of locations that remain compatible as the infrastructure network evolves.


Tipo de participación: Manuscrito completo