2026-11-11 –, Multifuncional (Remoto)
Identifying suitable regions for sustainable green hydrogen projects requires integrating spatially distributed renewable resources, infrastructure accessibility, terrain conditions, territorial constraints, and expert-based decision criteria for energy planning. Although green hydrogen siting is often approached as a problem of renewable resource availability, territorial deployment also requires transparent geographic suitability representations and procedures for transforming pixel-level scores into compact regions that can support planning decisions. This is particularly relevant in national-scale assessments, where high-resource locations may not coincide with accessible, feasible, or spatially coherent development areas. In this sense, green hydrogen siting is not only an energy assessment problem, but also a GIScience problem involving spatial representation, multicriteria modeling, and spatial decision support.
This study compares alternative geographic suitability representations for green hydrogen territorial planning in Mexico. The objective is to evaluate how different GIS-based scoring approaches influence the selection of compact priority regions when the same input criteria and an approximately equal selected area are used. Three multicriteria outputs are compared: a baseline weighted multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) score, a production-oriented MCDA score with greater emphasis on hydrogen production benefit, and a Gaussian Mixture Model (GMM)-derived expected favorability score. The purpose is not to identify a universally best method, but to assess whether selected regions remain stable when explicit weighting is compared with model-based clustering.
GIS-based MCDA has been widely used for integrating heterogeneous spatial criteria into suitability analysis. Its main advantage is transparency, because criteria and weights can be explicitly defined, discussed, and adjusted according to planning priorities. In contrast, model-based clustering provides a probabilistic framework for identifying latent multicriteria profiles. Here, GMM-derived favorability is used as a complementary geographic representation that identifies recurrent spatial profiles among eligible pixels and translates component membership probabilities into an expected favorability score. This contrast allows the analysis to compare a normative weighting structure with a data-driven multicriteria representation.
The analysis uses a common eligible spatial domain and a shared set of normalized criteria: hydrogen production benefit, accessibility to roads, railways, and the electrical grid, as well as slope and terrain ruggedness suitability. All criteria are expressed on a normalized 0–1 scale, where higher values indicate greater suitability. The baseline MCDA score represents a balanced model combining hydrogen benefit, infrastructure access, and terrain conditions. The production-oriented MCDA score increases the weight of hydrogen benefit and removes direct terrain penalties from the score, while maintaining the same eligible spatial domain. Therefore, differences among methods reflect alternative representations of suitability rather than changes in input data or exclusions.
To move from suitability scores to planning-relevant regions, each score is processed through a region-growing algorithm. This procedure starts from high-scoring pixels and expands through neighboring cells until a target area is reached. The process is applied independently to the states of the Mexican Republic and repeated across three rounds. Region-growing approaches are useful for converting local suitability values into spatially contiguous units. The comparison uses cumulative selected area, selected hydrogen potential, hydrogen density, and state-level pairwise differences. Mean scores are interpreted within each method and are not treated as direct cross-method performance indicators, because MCDA and GMM-derived scores are produced through different modeling procedures.
The results show broadly similar national-level outcomes under an approximately equal-area land allocation, but relevant differences emerge at the state level. After three region-growing rounds, the three methods select close to 9,605 km² nationally. The production-oriented MCDA produces the highest cumulative selected hydrogen potential, reaching 23,563.84 kt/yr over 9,604.83 km². The baseline MCDA follows with 23,483.64 kt/yr over 9,604.98 km², while the GMM-derived expected favorability score selects 23,171.93 kt/yr over 9,605.18 km². The production-oriented MCDA increases selected hydrogen potential by 80.21 kt/yr, or 0.34%, relative to the baseline. The GMM-derived score selects 311.70 kt/yr less than the baseline and 391.91 kt/yr less than the production-oriented MCDA.
Although national differences are modest, the state-level comparison reveals stronger methodological sensitivity. Some Mexican states are consistently prioritized across methods, indicating robust suitability signals, while others vary depending on the geographic representation used. The GMM-derived expected favorability score increases selected potential compared with the baseline MCDA in Morelos, Chiapas, Baja California Sur, Colima, and Yucatán, while it selects less potential in Veracruz, Tamaulipas, Nayarit, Quintana Roo, and Querétaro. These differences suggest that GMM-derived favorability does not simply reproduce the weighted MCDA ranking. Instead, it highlights alternative spatial profiles that may be more balanced across criteria but not necessarily the highest in hydrogen production.
This work contributes to GIScience by framing green hydrogen siting as a problem of geographic suitability representation and spatial decision support. MCDA provides a transparent and policy-oriented framework, GMM-derived favorability identifies recurrent multicriteria profiles without imposing a single weighting structure, and region growing translates continuous scores into compact priority regions. The main contribution is not the identification of a single optimal region, but the demonstration that methodological choices in suitability representation and spatial aggregation can alter state-level priority regions even when the selected national area remains approximately constant. The proposed framework can be adapted to other infrastructure and territorial planning problems where spatial representation influences decision outcomes.
Soy estudiante del Doctorado en Ciencias en Energías Renovables en el Centro de Investigación Científica de Yucatán. Mi formación académica es en Ingeniería en Energía y cuento con una Maestría en Ciencias en Energías Renovables. Actualmente desarrollo investigación relacionada con la planeación territorial del hidrógeno verde en México, integrando herramientas de sistemas de información geográfica, análisis multicriterio, evaluación de recursos renovables, accesibilidad a infraestructura y restricciones territoriales. Mi trabajo busca contribuir al diseño de metodologías que permitan identificar regiones adecuadas para el desarrollo de proyectos sustentables de hidrógeno, considerando tanto el potencial energético como las condiciones del territorio. Mis intereses académicos se enfocan en la transición energética, la modelación geoespacial, la planeación de infraestructura energética y el aprovechamiento sustentable de los recursos renovables.
Education: Master’s and Ph.D. in Computer Science from the Centro de Investigación en Matemáticas A.C. (CIMAT). Research: optimization algorithms, numerical methods, and parallel computing, with applications to geospatial and engineering problems, including optimal design, time-series model fitting for pollutant and climatological variables, prediction of violent-event counts and land-use change. Publications: over 100 in total, of which 40 are journal articles. Graduated thesis students: 2 at the doctoral level, 11 at the master’s level, and 6 at the undergraduate level. Research projects: principal investigator on 2, collaborator on 7, and reviewer for SECIHTI-Mexico. Serves as reviewer for several international journals and conferences. Recipient of 3 best paper awards at international conferences; member of the National System of Researchers at Level 2. Teaching at the undergraduate, master’s, and doctoral levels. Currently a researcher within the Investigadoras e Investigadores por México programme of SECIHTI, stationed at CentroGeo at Querétaro, México.
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5996-992X
https://publons.com/researcher/2104911/s-ivvan-valdez
https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=MG1jyREAAAAJ&hl
https://www.scopus.com/authid/detail.uri?authorId=57211028183
- Modeling classification thresholds for areas burned by forest fires considering phenological variability using Sentinel-2 images in Mexico.
- Typologies of land-cover loss to urbanization in Mexican metropolises between 2005 and 2020
- A graph theory approach to the geospatial analysis of femicide in Guanajuato
- Spatiotemporal quantification of crop cover changes using remote sensing in metropolitan areas of Mexico (2000–2020) and its relationship with agricultural production