2026-11-11 –, Multifuncional (Remoto)
Objective. In Mexico City, an informal market of private ambulances operates whereby units—presenting themselves as volunteer responders—insert themselves into emergency scenes dispatched by the 911 response system with the purpose of billing patients for transport services.
The presence of a private unit in the official incident record constitutes an irregular self-insertion, given that the protocol of the Centro de Comando, Control, Cómputo, Comunicaciones y Contacto Ciudadano (C5) dispatches exclusively public units. The behavior of these providers can be interpreted through the lens of spatial competition theory. For-profit suppliers tend to cluster around the economic core, in proximity to their competitors, rather than in accordance with the populations they nominally serve (Hotelling, 1929; Salop, 1979).
From a health equity standpoint, this pattern resonates with the Inverse Care Law, according to which the availability of quality care varies inversely with need in settings where services are exposed to market forces (Tudor Hart, 1971), and with the notion of spatial justice, which conceives the distribution of urban services as a mechanism that reproduces spatial power relations (Soja, 2010). This study examines whether irregular private ambulances follow a coverage pattern oriented toward income maximization or an altruistic one oriented toward population need.
Methods. An observational, cross-sectional study with a quantitative and spatial approach was conducted using traffic incident data recorded by the C5 of the Secretaría de Seguridad Ciudadana (SSC) during 2024, comprising 30,645 point-georeferenced events, of which 1,767 (5.8%) were attended by an irregular private unit. The analysis combined point pattern and areal techniques (Baddeley, Rubak, & Turner, 2015). First, a case-control relative risk surface was estimated—cases corresponding to private attendance and controls to public attendance—via the kernel density ratio, with tolerance contours derived through Monte Carlo simulation (Kelsall & Diggle, 1995; Davies, Marshall, & Hazelton, 2018); using public events as control fixes the demand surface and eliminates the need for a population denominator. Second, the global Moran's I with empirical Bayes smoothing and Local Indicators of Spatial Association (LISA) were computed on 1 km and 0.5 km grids with false discovery rate correction for multiple testing (Anselin, 1995; Assunção & Reis, 1999; Caldas de Castro & Singer, 2006). Third, a geographically weighted regression was fitted with an adaptive bisquare kernel and AICc-selected bandwidth (Brunsdon, Fotheringham, & Charlton, 1996); covariates were land unit value as a proxy for payment capacity, distance to the nearest private hospital as a proxy for billing destination, and commercial establishment density. The relative risk surface was replicated across temporal strata (weekend and early morning versus weekday and daytime) as a robustness contrast.
Results. The relative risk surface reveals a significantly elevated region (0.05 tolerance contour) along the high-value corridor connecting the boroughs of Cuauhtémoc, Benito Juárez, and Miguel Hidalgo, with markedly negative values in the southern and western periphery, where private response is virtually absent—consistent with spatial competition theory for for-profit providers (Hotelling, 1929; Salop, 1979). The most conclusive finding is surface time-invariance: weekend and early-morning strata are nearly identical to weekday and daytime strata, contrary to evidence on voluntary association availability. An altruistic logic would predict intensification of the central concentration during nighttime hours to fill gaps in public deployment; its absence indicates structural localization rather than opportunistic compensation. The global Moran's I reaches 0.471 (p = 0.001) at 1 km and 0.331 (p = 0.001) at 0.5 km. After false discovery rate correction, LISA identifies a compact high-high cluster (approximately 53 cells at 1 km) confined to the high-value core and encircled by a low-low peripheral belt dependent almost exclusively on public resources. Geographically weighted regression reduces the AICc by approximately 392 points relative to the global model, evidencing non-stationarity. Coefficients are consistent with income-maximization: land value and commercial density are positively associated with private attendance; distance to the nearest private hospital, negatively; patient transport, positively; and high-priority severity, negatively. The conjunction of a positive transport effect and a negative severity effect is determinative—the private unit is present where a patient is transportable and billable, not where clinical need is greatest, constituting a revealed preference for collectible revenue over need (Tavares & Rodrigues, 2013). Local coefficients for land value and hospital distance intensify along the central corridor and attenuate to zero in the periphery, consistent with profit-oriented agents self-selecting into the most lucrative submarket irrespective of population need (Monkkonen, 2018).
Conclusions. The convergence of the three analytical approaches—statistically significant point-level concentration, a robust cluster of contiguous high values, and local dependence on payment capacity and billing destination—indicates that the coverage pattern of irregular private ambulances is governed by collectible revenue rather than population need. Within spatial competition theory, the irregular unit behaves as a profit-oriented agent that clusters in the lucrative core while the public system absorbs the periphery; the evidence therefore positions it at the rent-seeking pole rather than that of the altruistic intermediary maximizing coverage (Monkkonen, 2018). The phenomenon materializes the Inverse Care Law in its purest form—under direct market exposure—and reproduces the logic of spatial inequality. Regarding public policy implications, expanding supply does not correct coverage, since profit-oriented providers would concentrate again in the lucrative zone; what is required instead is geographic regulation of the irregular private sector and active redistribution of public deployment. The methodological contribution resides in the point-process case-control design, which dissolves the population denominator problem and the modifiable areal unit problem by using observed demand as the control. Limitations include numerator bias (the registry only captures attended events, so actual inequity may be greater), potential spatial confounding between land value and economic centrality, and the cross-sectional nature of the design, which describes association rather than causation. These limitations inform future research directions, including multiscale geographically weighted regression, Bayesian point process models with latent fields, and the incorporation of response times and destination hospital for each event.
José Manuel Muñoz Carrillo es técnico profesional en urgencias médicas, economista y maestro en Economía Aplicada. Actualmente cursa el Doctorado en Política Pública en la Escuela de Gobierno y Transformación Pública del Tecnológico de Monterrey, donde su investigación se enfoca en problemas de inequidad en salud.
Cuenta con la Especialidad en Métodos Estadísticos con orientación en Bioestadística por el Centro de Investigación en Matemáticas A.C. (CIMAT), un Diplomado en Análisis de Datos en Salud del Instituto Nacional de Salud Pública (INSP) y un Diplomado en Salud, Bioética y Bioderecho del Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas de la UNAM. Este perfil le permite articular el análisis empírico riguroso con marcos normativos y éticos en investigación aplicada.
Su trabajo académico integra econometría, bioestadística, ciencia de datos y recientemente análisis espacial para el estudio de la distribución de servicios de salud prehospitalaria en contextos urbanos. Ha publicado en la Gaceta Médica de México y en ResearchGate, y ha presentado resultados de investigación en congresos nacionales e internacionales, incluyendo foros especializados en Colombia y México.
Es miembro de la Sociedad Mexicana de Medicina de Emergencias A.C.