Jorge Omar López Martínez
Sessions
Pinus hartwegii forms the treeline of the highest mountains of Mexico and northern Central America, in open subalpine forests between 2,800 and 4,100 m elevation. Because it occupies the cold, high end of the forest gradient, its populations act as early sentinels of climate change. Its distribution is markedly fragmented, spread across isolated summits —from El Salvador to the Sierra de Arteaga in northeastern Mexico—, which hampers continuous field monitoring and motivates the use of remote sensing to assess its trajectory in a homogeneous, regional-scale manner.
P. hartwegii is known to respond strongly to the environmental gradient: provenance trials document genetic and phenotypic differentiation along elevation —which has even prompted assisted-migration proposals—, while bioclimatic niche models project, under warming, contractions of suitable habitat and potential losses of up to three quarters of its area by mid-century. However, direct observational evidence of how the canopy has been responding in recent decades is scarce and is usually limited to individual sites. This work addresses that gap by analyzing NDVI trends (MODIS, 2000–2025) at 108 sites distributed across 20 mountain massifs spanning the species' entire latitudinal range (≈14.5°–25.3° N), complemented with monthly climate (TerraClimate) and topographic descriptors. Trends were quantified using the Mann-Kendall test and Sen's slope on deseasonalized series, and their environmental controls were explored with generalized additive models.
Over the past quarter-century, the summits that harbor the species have warmed steadily: regional mean temperature rose by about 1 °C, with a more pronounced increase in minimum than in maximum temperatures —warmer nights and fewer frost events—, while precipitation remained practically stable and the climatic water deficit (the atmosphere's evaporative demand) showed an upward trend. For a treeline species, cold-adapted and confined to habitat islands with no possibility of horizontal displacement, this warming is a cause for concern: it may transiently stimulate growth, but it may also push populations toward water-stress thresholds and toward greater pressure from pests and fire.
In this context, preliminary results reveal a dominant greening signal: most sites (90 of 108) show a positive and significant NDVI trend, against a stable minority and an almost total absence of browning. The magnitude is appreciable: accumulated over the 25-year period, it amounts to an increase in greenness of nearly 13% over the mean cover value, consistent with an increase in forest basal area and understory. The intensity of greening is governed by altitude —it is greater at the highest, coldest sites—, whereas latitude, terrain slope and slope aspect show no significant effect; the additive model confirms elevation as the main nonlinear control of the trend. Almost all sites also exhibit a break in the rate of change around 2011–2012, with a balanced mix of accelerations and decelerations reminiscent of the growth reversals described at other tropical treelines.
The predominance of altitudinal-thermal control, combined with the observed warming, invites several non-exclusive hypotheses about the greening mechanism: a lengthening of the growing season favored by higher temperatures and fewer frosts; the absence, so far, of water stress severe enough to counteract that thermal stimulus; and the possibility that warming has not yet decisively intensified the pressure of bark beetles and other biotic disturbances at these elevations. The interpretation, however, must be cautious and nuances the picture offered by niche models: higher NDVI does not guarantee persistence in the face of the habitat losses projected at the lower distribution limits, which the upper-treeline signal does not capture. Accordingly, sites with deceleration or a negative trend —often peripheral and isolated populations— are identified as priority candidates for monitoring, conservation and eventual assisted migration.
Methodologically, within the framework of the geographic information sciences, the proposal offers a reproducible and transferable protocol that combines long-term satellite series, climate reanalysis, and trend and breakpoint analysis to monitor fragmented mountain ecosystems. Its products —trend cartography and spatially explicit models of their environmental controls— constitute a quantitative baseline that complements niche models and the species' ongoing phenotypic and genomic characterization. The work is now advancing toward validation with higher-resolution imagery (Sentinel-2), phenological analysis, and formal attribution of the trends to climatic forcings.
1. Introduction
Reliable estimates of above-ground biomass density (AGBD) are essential for forest carbon accounting, REDD+, and conservation policies. Although Mexico's National Forest Inventory (INFyS) provides the most reliable field-based AGBD data, its limited spatial coverage and high acquisition costs constrain large-scale monitoring, particularly in tropical forests. Earth Observation (EO) products, such as ESA CCI Biomass and GEDI-derived canopy height, offer continuous spatial coverage but are affected by non-stationary relationships with AGBD and sensor saturation. Consequently, integrating EO and field data requires models that explicitly account for spatial dependence and uncertainty, making spatially varying coefficient (SVC) geostatistical models a suitable approach.
2. Research Gap
Models fitted over large, heterogeneous domains often borrow strength across broad ecological gradients and tend to shrink local predictions toward the national mean. While statistically efficient at the national scale, this can lead to regional miscalibration, particularly where Earth Observation (EO) covariates lose sensitivity. Both ESA Climate Change Initiative Biomass (CCI Biomass), which becomes weakly informative beyond roughly 150–200 Mg ha$^{-1}$, and GEDI-derived canopy height, which saturates near the upper end of tall tropical canopies, degrade precisely in dense tropical forests. Quintana Roo, with semi-evergreen tropical forest, secondary vegetation, coastal gradients, karstic substrates, and heterogeneous land-use histories, exemplifies this condition. A state-scale application therefore requires an independent modeling framework that jointly addresses response scale, data quality, and local covariate behavior, explicitly identifying where each EO source drives predictions.
3. Methodology
We develop such a reformulation for Quintana Roo within the SVC–SPDE framework. On a transformed response, the model is written in the standard additive form
$$ g{Y(\mathbf{s})}=[\alpha+\tilde{\alpha}(\mathbf{s})]+[\beta+\tilde{\beta}(\mathbf{s})]x_1(\mathbf{s})+[\eta+\tilde{\eta}(\mathbf{s})]x_2(\mathbf{s})+\epsilon(\mathbf{s}), $$
where $\tilde{\alpha},\tilde{\beta},\tilde{\eta}$ are mean-zero Matérn Gaussian fields approximated by the SPDE over a triangular mesh. The database combines INFyS plot AGBD, CCI Biomass, and GLAD-GEDI canopy height, harmonized around 2019, with covariates extracted as footprint-weighted means per plot. Because spatial covariance is inferred from the data, a single high-leverage record can distort local coefficient surfaces, so we applied a quality-control protocol—coordinate and unit verification, removal of duplicates and implausible values, and restriction to mainland forest. The SPDE mesh was confined to Quintana Roo rather than a national grid, improving computational efficiency.
The choice of $g$ matters once predictions return to the Mg ha$^{-1}$ scale, motivating our departure from the square-root response used nationally. Writing $\mu(\mathbf{s})$ for the linear predictor, the square-root link inverts by squaring, whereas the logarithmic link inverts by exponentiation:
$$ g=\sqrt{\cdot}: Y=\mu^2=\dots+2,\beta(\mathbf{s})\eta(\mathbf{s}),x_1x_2+\dots, \qquad g=\log: Y=e^{\alpha(\mathbf{s})},e^{\beta(\mathbf{s})x_1},e^{\eta(\mathbf{s})x_2}. $$
Squaring introduces covariate interaction terms, so the marginal effect of each covariate depends on the other and on the intercept, making EO effects entangled. The logarithm instead factorizes biomass into independent multiplicative terms, matching its power-law structure and preserving per-covariate effects. Zero-valued records were dropped, as $\log 0$ is undefined; since $\exp{E[\log Y]}\neq E[Y]$, predictions were back-transformed from posterior predictive samples. Accuracy was assessed with $R^2$, RMSE, MAE, and bias, calibration with leave-one-out Probability Integral Transform, and prediction structure through covariate-contribution surfaces $C_{\mathrm{CCI}}(\mathbf{s})=\beta(\mathbf{s})x_1(\mathbf{s})$ and $C_{\mathrm{GEDI}}(\mathbf{s})=\eta(\mathbf{s})x_2(\mathbf{s})$, with relative dominance $D_{\mathrm{CCI}}=|C_{\mathrm{CCI}}|/(|C_{\mathrm{CCI}}|+|C_{\mathrm{GEDI}}|)$.
4. Findings
The logarithmic formulation substantially outperformed the square-root one, returning an $R^2$ of 0.68 against 0.38, RMSE of 26.7 against 46.9 Mg ha$^{-1}$, MAE of 21.9 against 33.2 Mg ha$^{-1}$, and bias of 4.2 against 16.8 Mg ha$^{-1}$—a 78% gain in explained variance, a 43% reduction in RMSE, and a near four-fold reduction in relative bias, from 27.6% to 7.0%. These gains reflect the positive, right-skewed, heteroscedastic nature of biomass: aligning the linear predictor with multiplicative mechanisms prevents spatially varying coefficients from absorbing distortions arising from an unsuitable response scale. Applied locally, the PIT diagnostic confirms better-calibrated behaviour once variance is stabilised and anomalous records are removed.
Because the log scale keeps covariate effects separable, the contribution surfaces admit a clean reading that the squared scale does not. A coefficient map alone is misleading—a steep local slope contributes little where its covariate is near zero—so weighting each slope by the value its covariate takes reveals which EO source governs prediction at a given point. Mapping dominance over Quintana Roo exposes a spatial division of labor: zones where CCI Biomass carries the signal, where canopy height does, and where neither does and the latent field absorbs the residual baseline. This matters because similar canopy heights can correspond to different biomass densities depending on composition and degradation. Hunka et al. (2024) map spatially varying coefficients but stop there; carrying the analysis through to contribution and dominance turns a surface of parameters into an operational map of per-sensor reliability—and is coherent only under a response scale that does not entangle the covariates
5. Contributions
This study proposes an independent log-scale Spatially Varying Coefficient–Stochastic Partial Differential Equation (SVC–SPDE) formulation for tropical biomass that integrates quality control, a state-restricted mesh, and posterior-sample back-transformation into a unified workflow, improving performance in high-biomass regimes where Earth Observation (EO) covariates saturate. Its main contribution is the spatial decomposition of covariate effects using a logarithmic response that preserves separability on the natural scale, enabling identification of where each EO source governs prediction. The framework also supports posterior predictive aggregation over administrative and conservation units with explicit uncertainty, providing a transferable approach for biomass estimation.